Menu

Ten checks before you sign with an umbrella company

Published 7 October 2026 by The British Institute of Recruiters
Ten checks before you sign with an umbrella company

The salesperson from the umbrella company was polite, the margin was good, and three of your temps asked for them by name. None of that is due diligence.

Since 6 April 2026 an agency that supplies a worker employed by an umbrella company stands beside the umbrella for the PAYE on that worker's pay. If the umbrella does not account for it, HMRC's guidance says it can recover the shortfall from the agency that holds the client contract, and it will look to the agency first. The rule covers chains set up years ago as well as the one you are about to sign. So the question is no longer "is this umbrella well known?" but "can I show I checked?"

Here are the ten checks HMRC's guidance for employment businesses lists, in the order that gets you to the answer fastest.

1. Ask the worker for a payslip. Not the umbrella, the worker. A payslip shows whether the umbrella is operating PAYE as the employer and whether anything is being deducted that should not be. If a worker cannot produce one after a month, that is your answer.

2. Ask the worker for the reconciliation statement. It shows the assignment rate the umbrella received against what the worker was paid, with every deduction between the two. Read it against the rate you actually sent. A gap you cannot explain is skimming or avoidance.

3. Check the VAT registration. The umbrella should be VAT registered, charging VAT, and the number it gives you should check out on HMRC's service.

4. Check Companies House. The company name, number and registered address the umbrella gave you should match the public record, and the officers should be real people you can find.

5. Match the bank account. The name on the account you pay into should be the umbrella's own name. Payment to a differently named account is one of the clearest signs of a chain you do not understand.

6. Ask whether it outsources its employer duties. Some umbrellas hand payroll or employment to a third party. If so, that third party needs the same checks, because the risk sits with whoever actually employs and pays the worker.

7. See the employers' liability insurance. A current certificate, in the umbrella's name.

8. Verify any accreditation it claims. With the body, not from the umbrella's website.

9. Check for a Gangmasters and Labour Abuse Authority licence where the sector needs one. Supplying into a licensed sector through an unlicensed umbrella is an offence in its own right.

10. Issue the Key Information Document yourself. When the worker first registers, before any work-finding service, naming the umbrella, and again on any significant change. The umbrella cannot issue it for you, whatever it offers.

Then date the lot, write down who did the checks, and put them in one folder with the contract. Repeat on a cycle you set and keep to. HMRC's word for the standard is "regular, reasonable and proportionate", and a file that shows a check before the first placement and a check every quarter since meets it.

Two warning signs deserve their own line. A worker who asks for a particular umbrella because it promises more take-home pay is describing a tax avoidance scheme to you, not expressing a preference. And a Key Information Document you keep having to reissue because the employer's name on the payslip keeps changing is the signature of mini umbrella company fraud.

The full guide, with the rule itself, who it reaches, what sits outside it and the five questions agencies ask most, is on our hub, What are the umbrella company rules for recruitment agencies from April 2026?

BIOR Agency Members have the IR35 and Off-Payroll Working guide, the PSC and Limited Company Contractor Terms 2026 and the Key Information Document template in their library, and Ask BIOR for the question an umbrella cannot answer. Agency Membership includes the certification assessment. Agency Membership.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Have your own arrangements checked by your own solicitor or accountant before relying on them. BIOR accepts no responsibility for any loss arising from their use. Sources, HM Revenue and Customs, "PAYE rules for labour supply chains that include umbrella companies from 6 April 2026" and "Responsibilities for employment businesses working with umbrella companies" (gov.uk). Written by The BIOR Membership Team, 7 October 2026.